Golden-task evaluation harness
The machinery behind the word "proven." One harness that scores tools, models, prompts and skills against a fixed set of real, anonymised tasks — so every claim ("this model is better", "this prompt works", "promote this skill") is measured, not asserted.
The task set
A fixed, versioned set of real tasks drawn from our own work, anonymised:
- Feature on the scaffold — build a small feature in the project scaffold to spec.
- Legacy bug fix — a real defect in an anonymised legacy snapshot.
- Test generation — produce honest tests for a given module (scored on mutation, not coverage).
- Refactor — a safe refactor behind existing tests.
Each task ships with fixtures and an automated grader.
What's scored
- First-pass acceptance — did the output pass without correction?
- Gate pass rate — did it clear the merge gate checks?
- Cost — tokens / time to a passing result.
What the harness gates
- Tool/model selection — feeds the tooling scorecard and every radar ring-move for AI tooling.
- Prompt promotion — a prompt moves
trial → provenonly on harness evidence. - Skill release — a skill's golden scenarios run here before it's published.
Rules
- Same tasks, same graders, every time — comparability is the whole point.
- Anonymised — no client data or PII in the task set (UK GDPR); synthetic or scrubbed only.
- Versioned — the task set is itself in Git; changes to it are decisions worth noting.